ON THE APPLICATION OF THE NAME TEUTHIS TO A GENUS OF FISHES. By Theodoke Gill, LL. 1), Two SPECIES were originally referred to the geims Teuthls by Lin- iijeus, one of which Wiis later referred to the genns ^Siganus or Atnpha- canthus, and the other to the genns Acanthurns. There has beeii much diversity of opinion among recent authors respecting this usage. Dr. Giinther has taken Teutliin for Sif/annti, and I have adoi)ted the name in place of Aatnthurus. Dr. Jordan has wavered between the two systems. Immediately after the publication of articles by Gill/ and Meek and Hoffiuan,- in which Tmthis was accepted instead of Acan- ilmrus, he adopted tlie name with the same sense.' Later he dissented and expressed the opinion that "the change of the name of this genus from Acanthnrm to Teiithis, as made by Gill and Meek, seems unnec- essary. The name Teuihls was based by Linna-us on T. hepatus and T.jdVHs. Its first restriction was to the latter species, a representative of tlie Teutliis of Giinther, the Si(/((nas of Forskal."^ He has adhered to this opinion since. ^ 1 shall now proceed to demonstrate that this opinion is the result of an imperfect view of the literature. I. The name Hepatus was introduced informally into ichthyology by Artedi in 1738 and afterwards employed with a generic diagnosis by Gronow (Latin, Ch-onoiuHs). Gronow, in his '^ Zoophylacium," recog- nized twosi)ecies: (1) Heixitns vanda fronteqiie inermihns, and (2) Ucpa- ins vincronerejfexo ntrinque prope eaudam ; the former is an Acanthnrid and the latter a Siganid or Amphacanthid. Further, the Acauthurid iProc. U. S. Nat. Mas., VII, pp. 275-281, 18S4. ■^Proc. Aead. Nat. .Sci. Phila. 1881, pp. 227-231 ( 1881). sProc. V. S. Nat. Mus., YIII, p. 386, 1885. ^Pioc. U. S. Nat. Mu8., IX, p. 49, 1886. "Proc. r. S.Nat. Mus., XI, p. 5.52, 1888; XII, p. 650, lX8!t; XIII, p. 32S, ixHO; XIV, p. 113, 1891, etc. Proci'eiliiiirsof' the ruiled States National iluscuiii, \(il. .\\'III— No. U^^2. 179 180 APPLICATION OF THE NAME TEUTHIS—GILL. vol.xvih. was described from a specimen of the West Indian A. chirurgns, which was recorded l)y Dr. Giinther^ in 1861 as being then in the British Musenm. ir. The name Teuthis was introduced in the twelfth edition of the Sys- tema Natnra; by Linnseus ^ as a substitute for Hejyatus, and in fact liis kno\\ ledge of the group so called was originally chiefly derived from (irouow. From misapprehension as to the position of the ventral lins, he referred it to the "Pisces Abdominales" between Silurns and Loricaria, and it must be here recalled that he had already recognized thiee siiecies of Acanthurids which he associated with theCh.etodons, viz: C. (10) nigricans, G. (12) lincafns, and C. (13) friostegus. Had it not been for the misapprehension, he would doubtless have referred his species of Teuthis also to Chatodon. Linmeus was inferior as an ichthyologist to both Artedi and Gronow, and the only reason for rejecting the earlier and adopting his later name for a genus, is because the binomial nomenclature was not adopted by Gronow in the work cited. Accepting, as we do, these principles, Ave commence with Lin- njvus, and first have to iiupiire what that naturalist actually meant. All that is published in the twelfth edition of " Systema Natura^"^ couceiiiing Teuthis is here rei)roduced, it being recalled that the genus was referred to the Pisces Abdominales. 17(i. Teuthis. Caput autice swbtruncatiim. Memhr. hraiifh. radiis V. J)e«/('s siinplici serie, a^quales, rigidi, approximati. Hei'ati s. 1. T. spina utrinque caudali lecimibeute mobili. Brown, jam. 455. Teuthis fusca caTuleo uiteiis, aculeo siiiiplici litrinqne ad caudam. (iron, zooph. 353. Hepatus mucrone reliexo utriiiqiie propc caudaui. D-3iiiP.16.V.iA.JVC!... Seh. mus. 3, p. 104, t. 33, /. 3. Clia^todou fitriilesceus, dorso nisjro, Cauda u'qnali exalbido nigroque varia. Catesb. car. 2, p. 10, /. 1,./'. 1. Tardus rhomboides. Valent. hid. 3,f. 77, 383, 404. HahHat in Carolina, Amboiua. Caput marime declire. Dentes a^quales, rigidi, unica serie. I'iuna dor- salis radiis 2»'ii>ii^ 8 sp>inosis. Veutrales 1 spinoso. Analis 3 spiiiosis. Ad utrumqiie lattis caudw Spina ralida. siihulata, moMlis, crif/ibilis, recinnheii.s, in snlco latilans. .lAVrs. 2. T. cauda utrinque uuitica. Crron.zooph.3o2. Hepatus cauda Irouteque iuerniibus. D. if P. 15. V. f A. -.V C. • J'nieiit. iud.S,p.3o9,f.ilO. Leerviscb. Hahifat ad Javam. Corpus macuJis longitudinalibus cd-nilescentibus. Cauda hinata. Pin- narum ventralinm radius primus et ultivius spinosus. 1 Cat. Fish. Brit. Mus., Ill, p. 330. ^LinniJBUs, Syst. Nat., I, p. 507. •' Vol. I, p. 507. PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIOXAL MUSEUM. 181 The first of these species is evidently the same as the second species of Hepatus, while the second is the first species of Hepatus of Gronow's system. Linn;cus did not know these species, as such, through autopsy, and derived his knowledge of them almost entirely from Groiiow, simply adding some synonyms, in several cases erroneously. I repeat that the genus Teuthis of Linnanis was purely the result of misapprehension or ignorance; and the genus being misplaced in the order Abdominales, its characters contrast with those of any genus of that order, but not with those of species referred to the Thoracici, some of whose representatives, retained in the genus Cha'todoti, have precisely the same characters, and in fact are nearly related congeners of one of the species of Teuthis. The clniracters selected for the generic diag- nosis, too, are of tli& least value and not even apiilicable in all cases, the only important characteristic being the dentition, and in the expres- sion thereof Linn;eus was more successful than Gronow, although in other respects much inferior. Although almost all of the Linnoean genera were composite and many of them embraced representatives of a number of distinct fam- ilies, the fact that the JSwedish naturalist referred two generic tyi)es to Teuthis has appeared to some good ichthyologists a suflicient reason to ignore the name for either. Thus both Kner and Klunzinger adopted the names Amphacanthus and Acanthurus. Kner remarked : ' Der Name Teiilhis diirfte kauiii bereclitigt soiu, obigeu Gattnngsnamen wieder zii vei'draugeu, da Liun6 iliu wobl fiii" t^iuige Arteu dieser, aber aucli der Gatt. Jcati- ihiinis beuiitzte. Klunzinger observed :- Dar'Same Jmpliacanthiis ist vorzuzieheu, da Liune unter dem Naineu Tentliis sowohl eineu . I )n2>h« can thus ids eiueu Acanthunis beschriebeu hat. 111. In 1775 Forskal, in his "'Descriptiones Animalium [etc.] qua^ in itinere . orientale observavit." introduced new generic or group names for species severally congeneric with the species of Hepatus or Teuthis, in a some- what informal manner, but which, nevertheless, admits of no doubt as to his meaning and intent. The data maybe given in the order of the volume. First, on the reverse of the false title page (ii, but not numbered) succeeding the introduction and table of contents, is a list of "ISTova Genera," among which four " Piscium" are named, viz : Salaria. (Gadus3.) Scarus. (Scarus 11-18.) Siganuis. (Scarns 9-10.) Acantburus. (Chtetodon 88-89. ) •'• ' The numbers after the genera refer not to the nuuiber of species in the respective genera, but to the serial numbers of all the fishes described. - Kner, Novara Exped. Fisohe, p. 20.5, 186;"). 'Verb. k. k. zool.-bot. Ges. Wien, XXI, p.T.Ol, 1871. 182 APPLICATION OF THE NAME TEUTHIS—GILL. vol. xvm. Secondly, in the suoeeeding'Taun.t! Orientalis Conspectus " prefatory to the " Descriptiones Aninialiam'' ' the following names are to be found : Scarus : novum genus. 'Lmpoi^. 9 («) rhniUdns: Djezavi ycX SUjdn. [Arabic letters.] Nov. jrenu.s: Siyanus. 10 (b) stellatus. Gbiejehiin. [Arabic letters.] No corresponding mention of the name Acanthnn(.s occurs under Chrvtodon.'^ Tliirdly, on referring to the text (page 25) these species are mentioned in the following terms: Scanis novnui genus antiquo nomine S/cdpor. Character genericns: Dentium loco maxillie ipsie eminentes, margine deutato-crenatio, ossca'. 9. Scarus siganus; rivnlatus; maxillis continuis, coiiiplauatis, margine serrato- denticulatis : denticulis approximatis, tiliformibus; a medio labio paulatim decre- scentibiis. [A detailed descriiition of the species follows.] Obs. Videtur genus proprium una cum sequente constituere; quum Jiabitus prorsus ]troprius. Nomen Siyani de.sumtum ex Arab. Sidjan vel Sigian. 10. 8carns stellatus ; ovalis fasciis anuulis ca»ruleo-pallidis, subhexagoni.s, uudi- que contignis. The name Siganus was thus (1) formally proposed as that of a new genus or ''novum genus"; (2) the diagnosis of the "/S'carw.s' sU/anus^^ was related intentionally to thegeneric characters, as will he j)erceived by a comparison of it with that of the succeeding, and (3) the group was recognized as a natural genus on account of the peculiar habit or appearance of the two species for which it was jiroposed. The "new genus" was (piite properly adopted by Cuvier, for a time at least. In connection with Chfcfodon,^' a i)roposition was made to distribute the S])ecies of the Linnsean genus among three subdivisions, as follows: Genus Loc subdivisioncm admittit: (a) Chwtodon: dentibus filiformibus, brevibus, numerosis, multoruui ordinum, densis, acutis, iuferioribus seusiui minoribus. P. Br. radiis 6. Spin;c P. A. 3. (&) Ahii-def diif: dentibus maxillaribus unius seriei, iili- formibus, coutigui.s, submobilibus, obtusis, deutibus faucium nullis, annulo subtus circa oculos, P. Br. rad. 5. Spina' P. A. 2. (c) Acantliunin : dentibus unins seriei, rigidis, acutis, contignis, vel simplicibus vel lobatis. Cauda in utroque latere aculeo uno vel pluribus; exserto et rigido; vel iiiobili et recondendo. Diversum prorsus a Clia'todonte genus; aliquande propriam constituens faniiliam. This procedure was even less formal than the introduction of the genus Sif/cunis, but, nevertheless, the name uicitnihurus has been very generally accepted as a generic name for the species of the family dis- tinguished by the characters attributed to it. It is again to be recalled that the first Linuiean species of Tex this is congeneric with the Araufhnri of Forskal, while the other is congeneric with the two Sigani of the same author. ' Page X. ^ Pages xii, xiii. ^Page 25. PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM. 183 IV. In 1817 Ciivier, in the tirst edition of the "Eegne Aniniiir'i adopted the two genera of Forsk;il witli the following naiues: Lcs Sidjans. (Auijihacantlnis. Scliu.) Les Acaiitlinres. Bl. {Thelitis. L. Ilarpiinis. Forsk.) If this means anything, it must be that lie would adopt the name "Theutis" for, or at least limit it to, the ^^Acanthurcs,-' but the meaning is certainly ambiguous; the restriction, however, is not. In lS290uvier, in the second edition of the " Regne Animal."- retained the same genera nnder a different guise, viz : Les Sidjans. {Siganus. Forsk.) Euro de Commersou : Centrogastcr l. 1.S33. 1838. Teitilijidida', Bonaparte, N. Anual. >Sc. Nat., Auuo it, IF. ]>. 133 (Cycloidiu ), 1838. 1840. Acanihurhla', Bonapakte, X. Anual. Sc. Nat., Anno 2, I\', p. 190 (Cteiioidci ;, 1810. Tt'iitliiiJuhr, Bonapakte, N. Anual. Sc. Nat., Auuo 2. IV, p. 271 (Cycloidei), 1840. 1841. Acaniltiiridi. ISonapakte, Fauna Ital., Pesci, hit., p. [6], TheuflniiJidi. Bonaparte. Fauna Ital., Pesci, Int., p. [11]. 1846. Teuthi/ida; Bonaparte, Cat. Metod. Pesci Europei. p. 7 (with subfamilies Auipha- cautliini and Teuthyini), 1846. 1850. Tenlliiididd', Boxapartk, (_'(jn.sp. 8yst. Pisciuni, 1850. Originally Bonaparte adopted the family Theutyes of Cuvier, with the same limits attributed to it hy the great anatomist, but provided the regularly formed family name Teuthididte (1833) or, less correctly", Teuthydidii; (1838). In 1810, however, he widely separated the constituents of the old family in the following manner, only special characters being here reproduced : ctenoidei. Fauiilia 18. Acanthurid^e. Squamis ruvidis.' 8ubfau)ilia 47. Acaiithuritii. Radii dorsales spiuosi a mollibus baud dis- tiucti: pinuw ventrales thoracici. CYCLOIDEI. Fauiilia 45. Teuthidid.e. ; radii spino^^i plures iu ])iuua dorsali. unus saltern in anali et in utraque ventrali. Subfamilia Tetithidini. Pinna dorsalis uuica. The AcanthuridiTB contaiu typical representatives of the ftimily so called, but the Teuthididti' do not an&wer at all to the Siganids. The attribute of several dorsal spines and at least a single spine in the anal and each ventral, as well as the single dorsal fin, are descri])tive only of Acanthurids, and not Siganids. The cycloid scales are the only char- acters distinctive of Siganids, and iu 1842 Agassiz, in the seventeenth ' There is no adjective ruvidus in classical Latin, and it is not evident why scabris should not have been used as the exact e(|uivalent of what Bonaparte meant, instead of a latinized form of the Italian ruvido. 186 APPLICA TIOX OF THE NA ME TE UTHIS— G IL L . vol. x viii. livraison of his "Poissons,"^ gave the following views respectiug the Teuthyes : I)v la J'amUle des Teuthyes. Cette petite fauiille. iiui n'est composeee [sicj que de ([uelques genres, se distingue assez facilement par ses ^cailles, d'liue petitesse extreme, repandues eu trt'S-grande quantity sur toute la peau. II fant en ('diminer le genre Aniplaacauthns, ({ue ses grandes ^cailles cycloidiques et ses autres caracteres zoologi([ues obligent a placer dans une autre faniille. Chez le reste des Teuthyes, et notamiuent chez les Acanthures et les Naseus, les ecailles forment de petites escjuilles transparentes, lisses, depourvues de tout ornement et h^rissees, an bord post^rieur, de quel<[ues petites Opines assez eftil^es, qui ressemblent un pen a celles que nous avous rencontrees chez les Zanclus de la famille des Squamipennes. Perhaps it was this publijcatiou tliat again drew Bonaparte's atten- tion to the families, for soon afterwards he reverted to his original views as to the limits of the family, recombining his Teuthidid.t, and Acanthuridti^ in a single family, at first (18-4G) nnder the name Tenthy- idse, and later (1850) again resuming the name Teuthydidre. He made an advance, however, in the recognition of two subfamilies, Ampha- canthini and Teuthyini (184(1) or Teuthidina- (1850). VII. Teiithi.s is one of the many names intiicted on scientific nomenclature by Linnteus as a result of his proclivity to take classical names and ])ervert tlieni to the designation of forms which are not related to and possess no intimate characters or analogies in common with the species to which they were originally applied. The Teuthis {Tsuf){::) of the Greeks was a squid (Loliginid). but there was also a gregarious fish mentioned once by Aristotle- as the Teutlios {Tsutio:;) and respecting which nothing more is known.' It may be that Linnaeus intended to take the latter name, but in fact he took the former, and, therefore, as long as the i»rescnt code of nomenclature is retained, the surgeon-fishes, belonging to a family entirely unknown to the Greeks, must bear a name originally given to squids.^ The name Te?^f/ios, however, would only have the advantage in that it belonged to a fish, and its exact per- tinence is unknown. Teuthis itself has not been retained unimjiaired. It was transformed into Theuthis and Theutis by Cuvier (1798 and 1817), and gave rise to the family name Theuties,^ Teuthyei,^ Teuthyen'^ and Teuthyw,^ of Agassiz. 'Vol. I, p. 88. -Vol. IX, Chap. 3. •''It is quite possible that the Tfvflof may hare been placed among the true fishes inadvertently, ov that some error of a copyist has crept in. Teuiliis and Teuthos are both used by Aristotle as names of different kinds of squids. ■•The case is just as bad, if not worse, if Teuthis is used for the Sigauids. ■'"' Theuties, Agassiz, Poiss. Foss., IV, pp. xiii, 212. " Tciithijci, Agassiz, Poiss. Foss., IV, p. 41. ' Teuthyes, Agassiz, Poiss. Foss., I, 88; IV, p. 206. 8 Teuthya-, Agassiz, Ren. Brit. Assn. Adv. 8ci., 1844, p. 288. PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM. 187 luasiiHU'li as the oblique cases take -id {TsoOiq^ -cdix;), tho proper form of the tauiily name is Tenthirlida'. VIIT. The foregoing citations (which might have been mucli increased) are sutticient to demonstrate that Teuthis sliould be used in i)iace of Acan- tliurus and not of Sif/anus. From whatever point of view we look, we are forced to this conclusion. 1. The first species of Teuthis was an Acanthurid. L*. The genus Sio(ton, Swainson, Nat. Hist, and Class. Fishes, etc., II, pp. 255, 1839. =Acronuri(s, Ghonow, Cat. af fish collected and described, p. 142, 1854. =Acanthunis j> 1, Gi'NTHER, Cat. Fish. Brit. Mus., Ill, pp. 325, 327, 1861. =^Acyoinn-iis, Gunther, Cat. Fish. Brit. Mus., Ill, ]k 345 (young). <^Bhomhoii(les, Bleeker. <^Acanthuru8, Kner, Novara Fxped., Fische. p]). 210. 212 (c\c ludcs Scopas and Acronnrns). =Acant]iunis A. Rhombolides, Day, Fishes of India, I, p. 202, 1876. <^Acanfhurits, Gunther, Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist., (4), VIII, p. 320, 1871 (includ- ing Acronurus and Keris as pro))ab'lo young). i, GCntiier, Jouni. Mus. Godeffr., 1\, p. 106, 1875. =Teuthis, Gill, Proc. U. S. Nat. Mus., VII, p. 278, 1884. 188 APPLICATION OF THE NAME TEUTHIS—GILL. Diagnosis. — Teuthidicls with a pair of an trorse movable caudal spiues, strong- fixed teeth, o-rayed centrals, and generally 9 (rarely 7 or 8) dorsal spines. Ty2)e. — T. hepatits, hiNN ^li-Uii — AcanthiirHs chirnrgus, Blooh, etc. The forms actnally belonging to the genus Teuthis as here under- stood are the followino-: I'reseut names. Names of Giintlier iindtir Acantlmnia. Teitthis triostega Acanthxmis tiiostegus, I.iiniii T. guttata A. guttatus, Forst. T. hepatus A. chirurgus, Bloch. T. matoides \ A. matoides, U. & V. T. uigivfuncus A. nigrofuscus, Forsk., 1775. T. bipunctatuis - A. hipunctatus, Gtlir., 1861. T.nigroris A. nigros, (xthr., 1861. 3'. doreensis A. dorcensiK, C. & V. T. cliry.soioma A. eltn/sonoma, Bikr. T. rubroiivnctata A . ruhropiinctattis, Eiipp. T. maiginata A. inarginattis, C. & V. T. lineata -1. Uiieatus (Liiin.). T. striata i A. striatus, (). & G. T.sohal I A. sdhal, Forsk. 1\ undulata ! A. undidatjis, C. & V. T. dussumieri | A. diissumieH, C. & V . T.grammoiMla ' A. grammoptihts, Blkr. . T. caendea A. cwrule^m, Bl. «fc Sclin. T. lineolata A. lineolatus, C. ifc V. T. olivaeea \ A. olicacevg, Bl. & Sclin. T. pyrofcnis - \ A. pyrofcrus, Kittlitz. T. tennentii. T. gah in. T.mnnini/er T. glaucopareius . T. cclcbicus T. fuscvs T. loicd.sternon.. T. acliilles T. triangulus [A. triangulus, C. & V. T. fiate'rculus A. fratcrndui, C. «fe V. T.bahianus A. bahianus, Castelnau, 1855. A. tennentii, Gtlir. A. gahin, Forsk. A. nvmmi/er, C. & V A. glaucopareius, C. iV \ ■ A. celehicus, Bleek. A.fusctis, Steiiid. A. leucosternon, Benii. A. achilleg, Shaw. SPECIES ADDED SINCE 1861. Tnttlns aterrima 1 Acanthurus aterrimus, Gthr., 1871. 7'. polgzona ' I>liS. dorsali.D. S. albdVUDctatiix. S. vulpinus. javiis (L.) I -S'. raiialiculata (Park) i S. cdiicateiiafa (C. iS: V.) ■ S. ciiralUiiaiV. &V.) I i>. rt'i iniciilata (C. & V.) S. laluiriii thodi's (Bleek.) ■ ,S'. M(/. ,/■(('. A V.) .S'. /,(« rq